2012 Western Division Champions 
2013, 2015, 2016 Playoffs Newark Pilots Players
Catchers
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |
| 10 | Shaun Hillis | Iona | Fr. | Derby, Ct | R/R | 5’11 | 190 |
| 13 | Ty Syta | LeMoyne | Fr. | Hamburg, NY | L/R | 6’0 | 220 |
| 19 | Adam Zebrowski | St. John Fisher College | Fr. | Albany,NY | R/R | 6’4 | 195 |
| Tate Ballestero | Virginia | Fr. | Morristown, NJ | S/R | 6’4 | 192 | |
Infielders
| 3 | Michael Gorman | Iona | So. | Carmel, NY | R/R | 5’9 | 170 |
| 1 | James Wrabel | Seton Hill | So. | Harrisburg, PA | R/R | 5’8 | 165 |
| 9 | Bayley Jamanis | Seton Hill | So. | Lancaster, PA | R/R | 6’0 | 195 |
| 22 | Parker Denny | Seton Hill | So. | Arlington, VA | R/R | 6’0 | 205 |
| 8 | David Bermudez | Rider | Fr. | East Burnswick, NJ | R/R | 5’8 | 185 |
| 18 | Logan Stirr | East Stroudsburg | Fr. | Canadensis, PA | R/R | 6’2 | 205 |
Outfielders
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |
| 15 | Jordan Fiedor | Seton Hill | So. | Greensburg, PA | R/R | 5’10 | 180 |
| 11 | Kameron Reynolds | Mars Hill | Fr. | Cherryville, NC | R/R | 5’8 | 175 |
| 20 | Ryan Lee | Marymount | Fr. | Fredericksburg, VA | R/R | 5’10 | 205 |
| 6 | Over Torres | Bethune-Cookman | Jr. | North Haven, CT | R/R | 6’0 | 190 |
Utility
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |
| 7 | Dylan Duplechain | Mississippi College | Jr. | Mamou, LA | R/R | 6’1 | 190 |
Pitchers
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |
| 28 | Ryan Mueller | New York Institute of Technology | Fr. | Lynbrook, NY | RHP | 6’1 | 180 |
| Mike Sculli | Monroe Community College | Fr. | Canandaigua, NY | LHP | 5’10 | 175 | |
| 17 | Kenneth Westbrook | St. John Fisher College | Fr. | Binghamton, NY | R/R | 6’2 | 180 |
| 5 | Allen Murphy | St. John Fisher College | Jr. | Richburg, NY | R/L | 6’0 | 175 |
| 21 | Brandon Odehnal | Marryville University | So. | Fenton, MO | RHP | 6’4 | 210 |
| 31 | Ron Loomis | Oswego State | So. | Livonia, NY | RHP | 6’3 | 185 |
| 33 | Matthew Boyko | New York Institute of Technology | Fr. | Westbury, NY | LHP | 6’3 | 180 |
| Chris LeVere | University of Maryland Eastern Shore | So. | King George, Va. | R/R | |||
| 12 | Michael Sollitto | University of Massachusetts Dartmouth | Fr. | North Providence, RI | R/R | 5’10 | 190 |
| 23 | Dan Munn | Hilbert College | So. | Shortsville, NY | R/R | 5’10 | |
| 25 | Dylan Blanchard | Alfred | Fr. | Newark, NY | L/L | 6’5 | 170 |
| 27 | Devin Hicks | Penn State Behrend | Fr. | Midlakes, NY | L/L | 6’3 | 220 |
International
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |