2012 Western Division Champions 
2013, 2015, 2016 Playoffs Newark Pilots Players
Catchers
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |
| Liam Harding | Rider University | So. | Staten Island, NY | 6’1 | 175 | ||
| Alexander Hernandez | Nova Southeastern | Fr. | Pembrooke Pines, FL | 6’0 | 195 | ||
| Phil Ferranti | Monroe Comm. College | Fr. | Webster, NY | 6’1 | 195 | ||
Infielders
| Tanner Cooper | Stonybrook University | Fr. | Canadaigua, NY | R/R | 6’2 | 210 | |
| Grady Wright | Lincoln Memorial University | So. | Fayetteville, TN | 6’1 | 210 | ||
| Nic Kent | University of Virginia | Fr. | Gordonsville, VA | R/R | 6’2 | 175 | |
| Justin Graham | St. John Fisher | So. | St. Marys, PA | L/R | 6’0 | 170 | |
| Ben Cowles | University of Maryland | Fr. | Newark, NY |
Outfielders
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |
| Parker Tadlock | Angelo State University | Fr. | Georgetown, TX | R/R | 5’7 | 160 | |
| Dawson Bailey | Niagara University | Fr. | Porter, NY | R/R | 5’11 | 175 | |
| Christian Busby | SW Tennessee CC | So. | Bartlett, TN | R/R | 6’0 | 170 | |
| Zach Prystah | Kalamazoo College | So. | Northville, MI | S/L | 5’7 | 165 | |
| Richard Phillips | Notre Dame College | Jr. | Reynoldsburg, OH | R/L | 6’2 | 185 | |
| Stephen Edgett | St. John Fisher | So. | Webster, NY | R/R | 6’3 | 190 |
Utility
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |
| Andre Marchesseault | Lasell College | Jr. | Cheshire, CT | R/R | 5’11 | 184 | |
| Zavier Warren | Central Michigan | Fr. | Southfield, MI | S/R | 6’0 | 190 | |
| Giovanni Torres | Bates College | So. | North Haven, CT | R/R | 5’8 | 175 | |
| Matt Cerfolio | Columbia Univsity | Fr. | Indian Springs, AL | S/R | 5’10 | 180 | |
| Jared DeSantolo | Florida Atlantic University | Fr. | Tampa Bay, FL | L/R | 6’0 | 175 |
Pitchers
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |
| Trent Baker | Angelo State University | Fr. | Georgetown, Tx | RHP | 6’3 | 225 | |
| Alex Teska | St. John Fisher | Fr. | Cato, NY | RHP | 6’0 | 175 | |
| Ryan Marketell | Monroe Comm. College | So. | Webster, NY | RHP | 6’5 | 200 | |
| Ryan Winn | Bowdoin College | Fr. | Webster, NY | RHP | 6’0 | 200 | |
| Brandon Cruz | Nova Southeastern | Fr. | Hialeah, FL | RHP | 6’6 | 230 | |
| Chad Nelson | Jamestown Comm. College | So. | Jamestown, Ny | RHP | 6’3 | 220 | |
| Christian Bellew | Mississippi College | Jr. | Gulfport, MI | RHP | 6’2 | 180 | |
| Allen Murphy | St. John Fisher | So. | Richburg, NY | RHP | 6’0 | 175 | |
| Zach DeVito | Corning CC | Fr. | Newark, NY | LHP | 6’0 | 190 | |
| Zach Mann | Chattanooga State Baseball | So. | Union, KY | RHP | 6’4 | 225 | |
| Branden Odehnal | Marryville University | Fr. | Fenton. MO | RHP | 6’4 | 210 | |
| Matthew Walczak | Lincoln Memorial University | So. | Levittown, PA | LHP | 6’3 | 180 |
International
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |