2012 Western Division Champions 
2013, 2015, 2016 Playoffs Newark Pilots Players
Catchers
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |
| Shaun Hillis | Iona | ||||||
| Ty Syta | LeMoyne | ||||||
| Adam Zebrowski | St. John Fisher College | ||||||
Infielders
| Michael Gorman | Iona | ||||||
| James Wrabel | Seton Hill | ||||||
| Bayley Jamanis | Seton Hill | ||||||
| Parker Denny | Seton Hill | ||||||
| David Bermudez | Rider | ||||||
| Jack Kelleher | St. John Fisher College | ||||||
| Nick Nevins | LeMoyne | ||||||
| Logan Stirr | East Stroudsburg | ||||||
Outfielders
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |
| Jordan Fiedor | Seton Hill | ||||||
| Kameron Reynolds | Mars Hill | ||||||
| Jeff Wilson | LeMoyne | ||||||
| Ryan Lee | Marymount | ||||||
| Alexander Diamatis | Rider | ||||||
Utility
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |
Pitchers
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |
| Ryan Mueller | New York Institute of Technology | ||||||
| Joseph Dietz | Stevens | ||||||
| Kenneth Westbrook | St. John Fisher College | ||||||
| Ryan Winn | Bowdoin College | So. | Webster, NY | RHP | 6’0 | 200 | |
| Brandon Odehnal | Marryville University | So. | Fenton, MO | RHP | 6’4 | 210 | |
| Ron Loomis | Oswego State | So. | Livonia, NY | RHP | 6’3 | 185 | |
International
| # | Name | School | Year | Hometown | Bat/Throw | Height | Weight |